A fire drill meant to keep employees safe ended up turning into a workplace sexual harassment case.

An employee who had served the company for 15 years, earning RM5,121 a month, was dismissed for inappropriately touching a female colleague’s body during a fire drill. Unhappy with the decision, the employee took the company to the Industrial Court.

In the end, the Industrial Court held that the dismissal was justified and dismissed the employee’s claim.

This case offers Malaysian bosses and HR a very important lesson: when an employee does wrong, the company has the right to act, but disciplinary action must have a legal basis, sufficient evidence and a fair process.

How did a fire drill become a sexual harassment case?

On 30 October 2019, Malaysian Industrial Development Finance Berhad (MIDF) held a fire drill. A female employee was assigned to play a fire victim, while the male employee involved was a member of the medical team in the emergency response team.

According to the female employee’s evidence in court, the male employee touched her body four times without her consent at the back staircase. She also said that only the two of them were there at the time, which left her frightened. The conduct was captured on the company’s CCTV and became one of the key pieces of evidence in the case.

The core issue in this incident: even while carrying out a task in a rescue drill, an employee cannot disregard another person’s physical boundaries.

How did the company handle the sexual harassment complaint?

The company did not dismiss the employee immediately upon receiving the complaint. Instead, it started a disciplinary process:

  1. 30 Oct 2019Incident occurs during the fire drill and is captured on CCTV
  2. 11 Nov 2019Show Cause Letter issued, asking the employee to explain the allegation of inappropriate physical contact
  3. 19 Nov 2019Domestic Inquiry held; the DI Panel reviewed the evidence and charges and found the disciplinary charges proven
  4. 3 Dec 2019Employee notified of the DI findings and dismissed with immediate effect
  5. AfterwardsEmployee filed an unfair dismissal claim under the Industrial Relations Act 1967

Why did the Industrial Court side with the company?

The Industrial Court did not simply rely on the conclusions of the company’s internal DI. It went on to examine the relevant evidence itself:

5 key reasons the Court upheld the dismissal

1. CCTV footage
The relevant witness confirmed having viewed the CCTV footage and observed the employee touching the female colleague.
2. Direct evidence of the victim
The female employee who was inappropriately touched testified in person, describing what happened and how she felt at the time.
3. Corroboration from another witness
Another colleague also gave evidence that the female employee had told her about the incident.
4. The DI complied with Natural Justice
The Court found that the company’s internal disciplinary inquiry did not breach the rules of natural justice.
5. A clear disciplinary policy
The conduct was an offence under the company’s Group Human Resources Policy, which was sufficient to support the dismissal.

Ultimately, the Industrial Court found that the dismissal was with Just Cause or Excuse and dismissed the employee’s unfair dismissal claim.

The publicly available materials do not fully set out every defence the employee raised against each piece of evidence, so this article does not speculate about his specific explanations.

JP Asia HR & Employment Law Analysis

The following is JP Asia’s legal and practical HR analysis, not a direct quotation from the Award.

1. Sexual harassment doesn’t only happen in the office

Many bosses believe that if something doesn’t happen at an employee’s desk, in the office or during normal working hours, it falls outside the company’s responsibility. This is a dangerous misconception. Any activity connected to the employment relationship can raise issues of workplace sexual harassment and employee discipline, including:

  • Annual Dinner
  • Team Building
  • Company Trip
  • Training
  • Fire Drill
  • Client entertainment events
  • Company-organised social gatherings

A company’s Sexual Harassment Policy should not be limited to conduct inside the office. It should reasonably cover work-related activities and communication channels.

2. Sexual harassment isn’t just dirty jokes

Many people think that only sending pornographic pictures, making inappropriate remarks or demanding sexual favours counts as Sexual Harassment. In reality, workplace sexual harassment can also involve:

  • Unwelcome physical contact
  • Language with sexual connotations
  • Inappropriate gestures
  • Pictures and messages with sexual connotations
  • Persistent, unwelcome sexual advances

Of course, not every form of physical contact automatically amounts to sexual harassment; it still has to be judged on the nature of the conduct, the specific context and other evidence. But a company should not ignore an employee’s complaint just because the conduct is explained away as a joke, over-friendliness, or something that happened during a company event.

3. 15 years’ service is not a free pass

Many bosses face a dilemma when dealing with Misconduct by a senior employee: this person has been with the company for more than a decade and has contributed a lot in the past. Now they have committed serious misconduct. Can the company actually dismiss them?

Length of service and past work record can be factors to consider when deciding on disciplinary action. But long service does not exempt an employee from responsibility for serious misconduct. Where the company can prove that the conduct is serious and that dismissal is a proportionate punishment, a senior employee can be lawfully dismissed just like anyone else.

A company should respect an employee’s past contributions, but not at the expense of other employees’ safety and dignity.

4. A company cannot choose not to deal with a sexual harassment complaint

To avoid internal conflict, some companies ask the complainant not to make a big deal of it, or even arrange for both parties to settle the matter privately. This approach can expose the company to even greater legal risk.

Section 81B of Malaysia’s Employment Act 1955 sets out requirements for employers to inquire into sexual harassment complaints, and Section 81C deals with disciplinary action once a complaint is proven. Within the scope of the applicable law, the company should deal with such complaints in accordance with the law, rather than choosing to ignore them because the person complained against is senior management, a long-serving employee or key talent.

At the same time, the company should protect the complainant’s privacy, prevent retaliation, and ensure the accused employee has a fair opportunity to respond.

5. A Domestic Inquiry is more than just holding a meeting

Many HR practitioners think that as long as they appoint a few Managers to sit as a Panel and have the employee answer questions, the Domestic Inquiry is done. But a genuine DI is a law-based disciplinary hearing process, involving:

  • Clear disciplinary charges (Charge)
  • An impartial Panel with no conflict of interest
  • A reasonable opportunity to prepare and respond
  • Presentation and examination of evidence
  • Handling of witness testimony
  • Complete records of the hearing
  • Findings based on the evidence

Even the seating arrangements, the identity of the participants and the duties of each role should be considered in light of the procedural purpose behind them.

A DI is not there to prove the boss’s decision right; it is there to fairly determine whether the disciplinary charges are proven. HR must not only know how to run a DI, but must also understand why each step needs to be carried out the way it is.

Learn the DI process hands-on: 2-day DI course (with a mock DI hearing)

Employers & HR Key Lessons

Lesson 1: Preserve the original evidence
Once a complaint is received, promptly preserve CCTV, WhatsApp, emails, witness statements and other relevant records so that evidence is not lost or overwritten.
Lesson 2: The Show Cause Letter must be specific
Clearly set out the date and place of the incident, the conduct involved and the relevant allegations, so the employee can give a targeted explanation.
Lesson 3: The DI Panel must remain impartial
Inquirers must not presume the employee guilty. A disciplinary hearing should be decided on the evidence, not according to the boss’s instructions.
Lesson 4: The punishment must be proportionate
A company cannot find an employee guilty the moment a complaint comes in, nor can it overlook proven serious misconduct just because the employee has served for many years.
Lesson 5: A clear Sexual Harassment Policy
The Employee Handbook should expressly prohibit such conduct and set up complaint channels, an investigation mechanism, confidentiality measures, anti-retaliation protection and an appropriate disciplinary procedure.

Why do some companies win sexual harassment cases, while others lose?

What decides the outcome is often not whether the company received a complaint, but whether it can ultimately prove the grounds for dismissal. A complaint can be the starting point of an investigation, but it should not be the conclusion that leads straight to dismissal. The company needs a complete handling mechanism:

  1. Complaint
  2. Evidence Preservation
  3. Investigation
  4. Show Cause Letter
  5. Domestic Inquiry (where applicable)
  6. Findings
  7. Disciplinary Action

Each step has its own purpose, and none should be carried out merely to tick a procedural box. If the case later goes to the Industrial Court, the company must be able to show that its decision had a factual and legal basis.

For a case that also involved sexual harassment allegations but where the company ultimately lost, compare: 27 People Interviewed, Still RM358,400 to Pay: BFM Media Industrial Court Award 1630/2026.

A final reminder from JP Asia to bosses

An employee making a mistake is not the scary part. The scary part is when an employee has clearly done wrong, yet the company ends up facing a compensation risk because of a lack of evidence, inadequate systems or flaws in the disciplinary process.

At the same time, if a company ignores sexual harassment complaints, other employees may lose their trust in the business. Good HR Management must achieve two things at once:

Protect employees’ legal rights, and protect the company’s legitimate right to manage.

A management system without legal backing cannot truly protect the boss. JP Asia Capital helps Malaysia SMEs build law-backed HR management systems, including:

  • Drafting Employment Contracts and the Employee Handbook
  • Sexual Harassment Policy
  • Misconduct Investigation
  • Show Cause Letters and Warning Letters
  • Practical Domestic Inquiry training
  • Employee Termination Advisory
  • Practical Labour Law & HR courses
Want to learn how to handle employee misconduct properly and run a law-backed Domestic Inquiry?

Get in touch with JP Asia Capital. Hotline: 019-335 2899

Further reading: 27 People Interviewed, Still RM358,400 to Pay: BFM Media Industrial Court Award 1630/2026
Fired for Taking Free Company Gifts? Industrial Court Award 1592/2026
Employee Handbook & HR Policies for Malaysia SMEs

Disclaimer: This article is based on publicly available extracts of the Industrial Court Award and case reports, and is intended solely for educational purposes in business management, HR and Employment Law. It does not constitute formal legal advice on any specific case. Actual disciplinary and dismissal decisions should be assessed independently based on the applicable law, the employment contract, company policy, the facts of the case and the relevant evidence. Reference case: Mohd Azhar bin Atan v Malaysian Industrial Development Finance Berhad, Award No. 2399 of 2023.

JP Asia Capital Sdn Bhd Law-backed Business Autopilot & Management Consultants Time for business owners. Direction for employees. A legacy for the business.

← Back to Resources